• Costello Wedding Soup

October 17, 2017

I have loved adopting this recipe from my husband's family who live on this soup in the winter and never can have Thanksgiving or Christmas without it.  It is handed down from the Italian side of the family for generations and all ages look forward to it when it's cooking in a giant pot on the stove.


For Soup

Whole chicken (have used store bought roasted chicken and canned chicken broth to save time and still good but for that special day make sure you boil a chicken to get that great broth)
Cubes of chicken boullion
Chicken broth cans- get a couple big cans or boxes
Meatballs (recipe below)
One bunch of curly endive –coarsely chopped can use escarole if you can’t find endive
Parmesean cheese (the cheap kind- Kraft or Kroger brand)
3-4 eggs
1 c. milk
Seasonings like salt & pepper, Lowry's Salt, etc.

For Meatballs

1 lb. Ground beef
½ Onion, finely chopped (can omit if your kids don’t like onions)
3 Cloves of garlic, finely chopped/minced
1 Egg
Bread crumb mixture
Salt, pepper, parsley or Italian seasonings to taste.  (This is where the art comes in.)
½ c. Parmesan, grated

Mix all ingredients and form into very small balls like the size of a big gum ball.

Cover chicken with water and boil.
When chicken is fully cooked remove from broth and allow to cool.
Reserve broth.
Once chicken is cool cut off all meat and add to broth.  
While chicken is cooking prepare mini meatballs like the size of a quarter or big gumball. 
Add meatballs to broth and allow to cook in broth.
Add about 4 cubes of chicken bouillons or more so you get that good chicken broth taste.  Can add canned chicken broth instead or both.  Just taste it and go according to your taste buds.
Add a bunch of endive only coarsely chopped in medium size pieces.
Add in ½ c. of Parmesan cheese or more to taste. 
Season with Lowry's Salt and salt and pepper to taste.  Whip about 3-4 eggs together with a cup of milk.  When soup is fully cooked and hot, gradually stir in the egg mixture.  Continue stirring until eggs are cooked.  

Prep time and cooking time:  1 hour
Will make about 2 large pots.  Can freeze and can make ahead and refrigerate.   
Tips or advice:  Egg mixture - I like lots of egg pieces so I use 4.  Make sure you keep stirring soup while you are pouring this in and the soup must be almost boiling when you add the eggs.  

Photo: Tim Dineen

Photo: Tim Dineen

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in Recipes

21 Special Sandwich
21 Special Sandwich

November 01, 2023

Sheet Pan Fajitas
Sheet Pan Fajitas

May 04, 2023

Dillar's Figgy Goat Cheese Log
Dillar's Figgy Goat Cheese Log

June 10, 2022